When you are on the road, your speed is determined by the amount of power being generated from your quadriceps, which is then transmitted through the knees to the pedals and then the back wheel. Power is the product of force and cadence. If you want to maintain a set speed, you must continuously deliver a set amount of power to the wheel. If you lower the cadence, and want to maintain the same power level, more force must be applied via the knees per pedal stroke. Conversely, at a higher cadence, the same amount of power is being distributed over more pedal revolutions, reducing the force on the knee for each revolution of the cranks and pedals.
Interestingly, knee joint complaints increase at both ends of the cadence curve. At low cadences, tissue injury may result from the higher forces required for each pedal stroke. At very high cadences, the force on each pedal stroke is low, but pedaling coordination may deteriorate. The knee can begin to move less smoothly, causing subtle changes in patellar tracking and increasing stress on the patellofemoral joint. This is one reason knee discomfort can occur at both very low and very high cadences.
Another factor that may play a role is related to the pelvic rocking that can occur at low cadences. If you have ridden behind someone straining in a large gear at a low cadence, you have probably noticed them rocking their pelvis from side to side as they work to generate more force with each revolution. This pelvic motion subtly alters knee alignment and biomechanics with every pedal stroke, potentially increasing stress on the joint.
One of the most common cycling-related knee complaints associated with riding at too low a cadence for the amount of power being generated is patellofemoral pain syndrome. The pain is usually felt behind or around the kneecap and is thought to result from excessive stress on the patellofemoral joint. Although many factors can contribute, riding at a very low cadence may aggravate symptoms in susceptible riders. A common daily activity that reproduces the pain is walking up stairs but not on level ground. Why the difference? The force between the kneecap and the femur increases as the knee bends under the increased load of lifting your body weight up the stairs.
There are two different types of fatigue to consider when discussing the effects of cadence - musculoskeletal fatigue and cardiovascular fatigue.
Laboratory studies have consistently shown that oxygen consumption is lowest at cadences of approximately 60-80 rpm. Yet trained cyclists commonly select cadences of 80-100 rpm during endurance riding and even higher during racing. Why the difference? Elite cyclists are often willing to spend a little more oxygen to reduce local muscle fatigue. Preserving the legs is more important than maximizing metabolic efficiency.
Bottom line:
Simply increasing cadence does not increase a cyclist's maximum power output. Just as pedaling faster does not increase your maximum heart rate, it does not increase the maximum amount of power your muscles can produce. A cyclist already producing their maximum power output cannot increase that maximum simply by spinning their legs faster.
However, for any specific level of power output there is an optimal range of cadences. Spin too slowly and the muscles contract too slowly, causing power production to fall off. Spin too fast and the muscles become inefficient causing power to fall off.
The optimal cadence for any level of power production rises as power output increases. This is most obvious during sprinting, where trained cyclists often produce their highest power outputs at cadences of 100-120 rpm.
Interestingly, the cadence that minimizes oxygen consumption is generally lower than the cadence that maximizes power output. Laboratory studies find the greatest metabolic efficiency at 60-80 rpm, yet competitive cyclists commonly choose cadences of 90-100 rpm during hard efforts. This suggests that optimal performance is about more than oxygen economy alone.
The practical implication for recreational cyclists is to avoid chasing a specific cadence with the idea that it will maximize power. Instead, focus on finding a comfortable cadence for the effort being performed. As power demands increase during sprinting or climbing steep hills, most cyclists naturally increase their cadence because it feels more comfortable and sustainable. The body tends to select a cadence that balances power production, muscle fatigue, and metabolic efficiency for the task at hand.
There are two ways to analyze cadence efficiency: mechanical efficiency and metabolic efficiency.
MECHANICAL EFFICIENCY
Mechanical efficiency refers to the delivery of power from the legs to the pedals with minimal stress on the joints, tendons, and connective tissue. It is the delivery of that power through a smooth, circular pedal stroke. At very high cadences, this can become a challenge as pedaling coordination deteriorates, producing a less controlled pedal stroke. Even at mid-range cadences, it is important to maintain a smooth circular pedal stroke where one leg is pushing down while the other is smoothly unweighting the opposite pedal. Cadence training can improve pedaling smoothness and expand the range of cadences that feel comfortable and efficient.
METABOLIC EFFICIENCY
Metabolic efficiency refers to how efficiently the body uses oxygen and fuel to produce energy. Laboratory studies show that oxygen consumption is lowest at cadences of about 60-80 rpm.
However, the differences are relatively small and must be balanced against the greater muscle and joint forces that occur at lower cadences. Many trained cyclists, focused on performance, regularly choose cadences somewhat higher than those that produce the greatest metabolic efficiency. This helps explain why the cadence that is metabolically most efficient is not always the cadence chosen by competitive cyclists.
There is no single cadence that is optimal for every rider. The majority of studies find that cadences between 70 and 90 rpm perform well across a wide range of measures. For any individual cyclist, however, the ideal cadence depends on fitness, muscle fiber composition, riding experience, terrain, and the intensity of the effort being performed.
Several studies support this conclusion:
New cyclists often begin with lower cadences in the 60-70 rpm range. As fitness, coordination, and riding experience improve, many gradually move toward cadences closer to 80 rpm.
The ideal cadence is high enough to avoid "lugging" with excessive pressure on the knees during each pedal stroke, but not so high that pedaling becomes uncoordinated. With experience, riders become more aware of pedal pressure and learn to adjust their gearing before cadence changes become excessive.
When pedal pressure begins to increase and cadence starts to fall, experienced riders shift to a lower gear and cadence rises in response. Likewise, when cadence begins to increase excessively, they shift to a higher gear and settle back into their preferred cadence range. For most recreational cyclists, that range will fall somewhere between 70 and 90 rpm.
If your cycle computer does not display cadence, you can easily estimate it. Set the display to show seconds and count the number of times one foot reaches the bottom of the pedal stroke during a 15-second interval. Multiply by four to estimate your cadence in revolutions per minute.
One of the best ways to identify your preferred cadence is through simple experimentation. After a thorough warm-up, ride a familiar stretch of road at a hard but sustainable effort. Note your time, heart rate, and perceived exertion. After recovering, repeat the ride at the same effort but in a lower gear that allows a noticeably higher cadence. Compare the results. Most cyclists find that a somewhat higher cadence produces similar or faster times with less leg fatigue.
Find a gentle downhill grade. Shift into an easy gear and gradually increase your cadence until your pelvis begins to bounce on the saddle. Back off slightly until the bouncing stops. Hold that cadence for about one minute while concentrating on a smooth, relaxed pedal stroke. Repeat several times. Relaxation is the key to pedaling smoothly at high cadences. Keep your shoulders, elbows, and hips loose.
A moderate tailwind can also be used to practice higher cadences. Shift into a comfortable gear and gradually increase cadence to 100-110 rpm. Hold it for 30 seconds, then gradually return to your normal cadence. Repeat several times while concentrating on maintaining a smooth pedal stroke.
It got me thinking that if I could have gone to a lower gear and used a higher cadence I could have maintained the same speed and maybe used similar power to my lighter friends? Then the conversation went to crank length (mine is 175) and the whole think started to seem overly complex with too many theories and a cafe seemed the best idea! - Bill
A. A complex question, but these comments may help to make it a bit clearer.
There is no formula that takes your weight and tells you the "correct" cassette, chainring, or cadence. The goal of gearing is simply to allow you to ride within a comfortable cadence range over the terrain you expect to encounter.
The key concept is that power output and cadence are not the same thing. Assume you are riding at your maximum sustainable effort and producing a certain number of watts. You can deliver that power at a variety of cadences. A higher cadence means less force is applied with each pedal stroke, while a lower cadence means more force is applied with each pedal stroke. The total power delivered to the rear wheel can be exactly the same in either case.
This means that switching to a lower gear and increasing your cadence would not necessarily allow you to produce more power or climb faster. What it would do is reduce the force required with each pedal stroke and, for many riders, make the effort feel more comfortable and place less stress on the knees.
Your weight is the bigger issue. On a climb, some of the power produced by your muscles is used to move the bike forward, but much of it is also used to lift your body and bicycle against gravity. A heavier rider therefore requires more power to maintain the same speed uphill than a lighter rider. On the flats, however, heavier riders often have an advantage because they typically possess greater absolute muscle mass and power, while aerodynamic drag is determined more by frontal area than body weight.
This explains why larger riders often perform well on the flats but struggle relative to lighter riders on long climbs. Even if you are producing more watts than your lighter companions, a larger percentage of those watts is being used to lift your additional body weight uphill. (see the section on energy requirements of cycling)
I did have an email from Bill a little later and here is his feedback:
"I was fine on gentle to average climbs because I could maintain a cadence of 90 but on any long steep climbs this would drop to 60 and I found it hard work. Using Sheldon Brown's tables I could see that a cadence of 90 on a 29 ring gave more speed and was easier on the legs than a cadence of 60 on a 25 ring. So for the mountains I have a cassette that allows me to do this which helps get my 90 kgs up the hill! Thanks again. "